it’s an ordered world: plane enjoyment

The essential element in any classical composition is order. Although, all composition is order in one form or another, in classical composition order is associated with the idea of repose and possibly can exist for itself alone as an exercise, a stylistic gesture within confines rather than an imaginative projection into the realm of infinity.

A classic case of order, perfect order would be Vermeer’s The Artist In His Studio, where the space is tightly limited and defined, and within that room the various objects are so disposed that removing or altering any one of them would create a disconnect, a rupture, with the compositional sense of perfect order created by Vermeer.

--- Text from Kenneth Clark, Looking at Pictures. I SUPPOSE that the natural feeling of anyone looking at Vermeer's Painter in his Studio for the first time would be pleasure in the daylight which falls on the patient model and passes over the map of Holland on the wall, like an incoming tide over the sand. We enjoy a moment of heightened perception, a simple pleasure of the eye; and Vermeer's early admirers were thus deluded into thinking that he was a simple artist. Yet from the start all sorts of complicating factors have entered in. Before my eye can reach the peaceful figure in blue, with her yellow book, it has had to leap some curious obstacles, the swag of curtain, the bizarre silhouette of the painter and the objects on the table, foreshortened almost out of recognition. As I gradually become conscious of these details I begin to notice how curiously they are seen and related to one another.---click image for source...

— Text from Kenneth Clark, Looking at Pictures.
I SUPPOSE that the natural feeling of anyone looking at Vermeer’s Painter in his Studio for the first time would be pleasure in the daylight which falls on the patient model and passes over the map of Holland on the wall, like an incoming tide over the sand. We enjoy a moment of heightened perception, a simple pleasure of the eye; and Vermeer’s early admirers were thus deluded into thinking that he was a simple artist.
Yet from the start all sorts of complicating factors have entered in. Before my eye can reach the peaceful figure in blue, with her yellow book, it has had to leap some curious obstacles, the swag of curtain, the bizarre silhouette of the painter and the objects on the table, foreshortened almost out of recognition. As I gradually become conscious of these details I begin to notice how curiously they are seen and related to one another.—click image for source…

In Poussin’s The Funeral of Phocion there is a similar attachment to perfect order within a bounded space. Here the sky is conceived  as a backdrop terminating a stage set rather than a continuation of spece in nature. We are however, free to wander at will within this picture within the space abundant around the forms. More specifically, we are led to wander, directed as it is with no emergency exit for escape, but the objects are so harmoniously ordered that we do not feel imprisoned.

---The following illustration presents an analysis of the linear perspective system of the Poussin painting. The red lines are the orthogonals that intersect at the vanishing point while the blue line is the horizon line of the painting which articulates the eye-level of the defined viewer of the painting. The vanishing point of the Poussin painting is equivalent to the tip of the gnomon which defines the point of view used by the artist drawing the nude in the Dürer illustration. Look at how everything makes sense in the Poussin painting from this point of view. ---click image for source...

—The following illustration presents an analysis of the linear perspective system of the Poussin painting. The red lines are the orthogonals that intersect at the vanishing point while the blue line is the horizon line of the painting which articulates the eye-level of the defined viewer of the painting. The vanishing point of the Poussin painting is equivalent to the tip of the gnomon which defines the point of view used by the artist drawing the nude in the Dürer illustration. Look at how everything makes sense in the Poussin painting from this point of view. —click image for source…

Poussin uses a number of devices that do not detract from spontaneous enjoyment, rooted as they are, in the artist’s feeling for what is right. A basic here is the repetition of the picture plane: the picture plane is repeated again and again as the objects recede towards the final backdrop which is the sky. A second series of planes at an angle to the picture plane is also suggested by the side plane of the wall forcing us to enter the picture from the lower left corner and moving across it, but we are impeded from moving out by the tall tree at the right and by this pane of the wall, which is turned to deflect the “current” of uor movement back into the picture. Like sheep being herded, even though this plane is in fact a distortion of true perspective.

This entry was posted in Art History/Antiquity/Anthropology, Feature Article, Ideas/Opinion and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>